 |


Welcome to Salsa
and the City! This is a new monthly column by Erin
about Salsa in the Circle City. Salsa has become a lifestyle for some of us: music,
dance, parties, fashion, travel, friends, relationships, and, did I say dance?
For those who are addicted to Salsa, this is a place where you can read about
what's going on in the city, and share your ideas, comments, and gossip. Erin
has been a regular of Indy's Salsa scene since 1998.
Do you Dance my Language? by Erin
Lamb
posted November 14, 2007
A question was posed on the website lavozmagazine.com about one year ago that I think would be interesting to discuss with the Indianapolis salsa crowd: Does one have to understand Spanish when dancing salsa?
My answer to that is: it depends. What I like about salsa music is the lyrics are very fun. They are not always about love like one might think. Often times they discuss cultural aspects of Latin America like the food or religion. Other times, like in the song, "Rebelión" by Joe Arroyo, it discusses slavery. This song is so upbeat and well-loved by dancers that a non-Spanish speaker would never guess the song was telling a serious story. Other songs are about running out of money or getting put in prison.(Sounds like country music or the blues - eh?)
However, for purposes of dancing socially - no - you need not understand Spanish. Even though "Rebelión" is about a sad subject, you are not going to dance to it in a depressed fashion even if you understand the lyrics. The beats are too fast! The music is too fantastic! It is more important that you recognize the beats and other instrumental elements of the song. Musicality is the key when you are a dancer. If the song has a pause, or a sudden change in the music, you should try to interpret that with your body. Otherwise, you may as well be dancing to the same song again, and again, and again. Plus, as a woman, when I really know a song, and I know when a good part is coming up, I hate it when the man just ignores it and keeps doing pattern after pattern. Cross-body lead, turn, turn, cross-body lead turn turn turn, cross-body lead blah . . . blah . . . blah.
I do, however, think it is very important that if you are a choreographer that you should understand Spanish. Dancing choreography is the art of taking a song - a story - and physically interpreting it for your audience. In order to do great choreography, you have to figure out what that song is trying to say. If you don't understand the lyrics, then you can forget it. For example, a choreographer who doesn't speak Spanish decides to choreograph, "Todopoderoso," by Hector Lavoe, (meaning Almighty or All-powerful in English) because he/she likes the energy of the song. He/She decides that they want this to be a very sexy piece and the women are going to do provocative moves with the men and wear little to nothing. Later, after performing the piece a number of times, the choreographer finds out from friend that the song is about Christ, his sacrifices, and his love for humankind. Who feels like a big dummy now? My point is, if you are going to do a choreography, you had better at least have someone interpret the lyrics for you before you put yourself out there.
So that is my opinion on the subject. I am interested in hearing what the rest of Indianapolis has to say.
Past Columns
Reader's comments
Does one have to understand Spanish when dancing salsa? NOPE! For all I understood after watching a clip of opera in a language I cannot comprehend. Brought tears to my eyes. Made me realize the there is some substance in what someone told me once, that the language of music and songs are UNIVERSAL. Check this video out and draw your own conclusions. This from a American Idol Version in Europe. Never ever thought that I would be moved listening to Opera! Good god, it even Shocked the xxxx out of Simon of American Idol.
- Vino
Good article... Sometimes I feel intimidated by dancers who also can also speak the language. I took one spanish class before, but it's just enough to understand basics, not an entire song... Sometimes I feel like they do have an advantage, but like you said, in social dance you are not interpreting the lyrics, but the musicality of the song. I think that is one of the great reasons why salsa has gained such popularity, because it is not restricted to one cultural group, but available to all! Even though I agree with you that one should understand Spanish when creating a piece of choreography, I do not agree that choreography necessarily NEEDS to interpret the song... that is one very popular choice, but not the only choice... Anyway, great topic to write about, Erin :-)
- Jennifer / Luna
Dancing without understanding the lyrics is like eating without tasting the food. Sure, you can go through the motions and eat. But, you won't know when to pause, lick your lips and say, "Hmm...this is so good!" You might put whipped cream on your meatballs or ketchup on your chocolate cake. The music can take you only so far. The rest is in the lyrics.
- Anonymous
No, a person does not need to know Spanish to enjoy or dance Salsa music or any other Spanish music for that matter. But, you do miss out on the lyrics and the messages that some songs have. But, there is other aspects where language does become important such as choreography. It is also important if you are a DJ. If you do not know what the song is saying that you are playing you better ask somebody. There is some songs out there that drive a political point or other social issues that people from various parts of Latin America can find very offensive. So enjoy the music and dance the night away and let the party continue at El Meson with Los VIP Cew and IntoSalsa. Pa que pa que lo sepan!!! Fuego!!! No hay agua que apague este fuego!!!!
- Aztecprinz from Los VIP Crew
Naw!!! I just dance to the music. Sometimes I find myself singing some of the lyrics, but I don't understand it. I've just heard it a lot and it's stuck in my head.
- ~Chimere~
Great comparisons by Anonymous, But I do not agree, cause it kind of reminded me of dogmatic statements. "Only Mexicans should eat at Taco Bel" "Only Americans should eat at McDonalds" "Only Italians should eat at Olive Gardens" "Only Indians should have Butter Chicken" "Only the Chinese should have fried rice" "Only the French should have French Wine" "Only the Swiss should eat Chocolate"..... because they understand the food and they are able to appreciate the taste. And the rest of the world are eating the food with out tasting the food.
Ewww! how narrow could we get in terms of been proud and not encouraging the spread of something good and wonderful.
- Vino
Vino, I agree that we should encourage what is good and wonderful. I encourage you to study Spanish and learn the lyrics. Then you will know what you have been missing. Imagine tasting something for the first time. Que rico!
- Anonymous
I'd like to make two points. 1. There're native dancers who understand all the words and they sing along the lyrics with passion when they dance. Then there're dancers who don't know the words or the language, but they interpret the music by hitting all the pauses, breaks, accents, and turning their own body into an instrument. To me they are equally impressive. There're so many aspects to Salsa music. It's up to the dancers to express themselves in their own ways. That's what makes Salsa dancing fun and beautiful. 2. Some Salsa songs don't have any lyrics, so language is not an issue. I'd like to share one of my favorite videos. Watch how Alex Lima, a Brazilian Salsa dancer interpret the music: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-z5fzuavXGA.
- Yang
NO...TU NO TIENES QUE HABLAR ESPAÑOL PARA BAILAR Y GOZAR EL RITMO DE LA SALSA SI QUIERES ENTENDER LAS LETRAS Y SENTIR LA EXPERIENCIA COMPLETA THEN YOU DO NEED TO HABLAR SPANISH REMEMBER THE KEY WORD RITMO BUT/PERO IF YOU UNDERSTAND THE LYRICS THEN YOU WILL HAVE GONE IN A COMPLETE JOURNEY OF THE RHYTHM, BEAT & LYRICS. SO QUE SIGA LA SALSA BUT YOU WILL DANCE TO THE RHYTHM & BEAT, STILL YOU WILL ENJOY PART OF THE CULTURA. BUT IF YOU REALLY WANT TO FEEL IT/SENTIRLO & UNDERSTAND IT/ ENTENDERLO....THEN YOU WILL NEED TO HABLAR & READ SPANISH ;-)223 GOOD BLESS AMERICA LOL.
- ;-)223
I don't believe that you should know Spanish to be able to dance but great point to who ever said "to go on a complete journey" it's ideal to know the language. I have found in the past that some who don't speak the language often ask their dance partner who does..."what are they saying?" (in the song), so i think that there's an obvious interest in people understanding what's being said because like us, they want to experience the dance to the fullest. One person who I love to watch dance Salsa doesn't speak Spanish and enjoy watching her (Chimere)dance...so to all, wether you speak Spanish or not, dance the night away as if no one cares. EL MESON is the spot to do it at!!!!!!!! Pa Que - Pa Que Lo Sepan...FUEGO FUEGO!!!! No hay AGUA que apague este FUEGO!!!!!!!! Ya Tu Sabes!!!
- Gino from LosVIPCrew
INtoSalsa, Indy's premier Salsa guide |  |
|